Project Augustine

Home » Church History » “Christianity: The First Three Thousand Years” by Diarmaid MacCulloch » Chapter 1: “Greece and Rome (1000 BCE – 100 CE)”

Chapter 1: “Greece and Rome (1000 BCE – 100 CE)”

Howard

Greece had a significant influence on Christianity and ironically had it’s beginnings before even Christianity developed.  Greek influence spread far and wide due to Alexander’s Hellenist conquest, Rome itself adopted and assimilated much of it.

Greek concepts such as an afterlife became deeply ingrained into even Jewish thought and Christian ideas such as Christ, Alpha and Omega.  Greek philosophers gave new compelling views of God, Plato’s gave the concept to look beyond the everyday mundane to a more  deeper or ultimate nature of reality.  They contributed much to Christian thought and theologians could be divided to their different schools of thought.

Even today I have seen their influence.  Christian philosopher Peter Kraft wrote several books detailing how Socrates after taking the hemlock and closed his eyes, opened them to having somehow been transferred to a modern college campus.  After enrolling in Christianity 101   he applies his Socratic method to question and learn who is this Jesus (Socrates and Jesus).

Another work of fiction was the book “the Name of the Rose” revolved around a medieval monastery library which may have contained a copy of Aristotle’s second volume of Poetics.  Some felt the book was extremely dangerous to Christianity and many died from it.

From common grace we know that God is reflected throughout this world even if it isn’t directly.  All good things ultimately come from Him.  We don’t need to fear or reject something just because it didn’t directly descend from high.

  

Danny

In this chapter, MacCulloch described the immense impact Greek culture and thought had upon not only Western culture but also the traditions and thoughts of Christianity that are present today.  For me, the greatest influence the Greeks provided for Christianity that is still very much prevalent today is the philosophy of Plato.

For starters, Plato’s “view of reality and authenticity propelled one basic impulse in Christianity, to look beyond the immediate and everyday to the universal or ultimate.”  His allegory of the cave has eerie similarities with Christian thoughts about repentance and conversion – that we are all imprisoned and must set our eyes elsewhere, above our senses, in order to find true freedom from the illusions of everyday life.  He also focuses a lot of attention on the soul, or the intellect, and the separation between the body and the soul, and this dualism is laced in the Christian understanding of humanity and the afterlife.  He believed that everyone should focus their souls on the Forms (his view of ultimate reality/truth) to the Supreme Soul (i.e. God).

Furthermore, as MacCulloch also points out, our understanding of God as being one and good directly borrows from Platonic thought.  He also “made ethics central to his discussion of divinity.” (loc. 623)  Our thoughts about an unchanging, eternal, perfect, and infinite God are also directly shaped by Plato’s theology.  Unfortunately, this also led to the belief that God was too transcendent that he lacked emotions or passions, and was therefore not subject to change, contrary to how the Scriptures portrayed God; this belief is still prominent in Christianity today.

Also, his negative views on the influence of the arts can also be seen in many Christian fundamentalist circles today, where such things like secular music, movies, video games, and culture are shunned at as having harmful effects upon the youth and their moral/ethical upbringing, which causes them to view the world as being not good, and the spiritual being more real and good.

Suffice it to say, Plato’s impact on Christianity was huge.  Even in the NT when we read Paul, we can hear echoes of his thoughts: “Though outwardly we are wasting away, yet inwardly we are being renewed day by day.  For our light and momentary troubles are achieving for us an eternal glory that far outweighs them all.  So we fix our eyes not on what is seen, but on what is unseen is eternal.” (2 Cor. 4: 16 – 18)  It would be utterly foolish to overlook or ignore the thoughts of Plato in any serious discussion about theology and Christianity.


3 Comments

  1. Tim Snoddon's avatar Tim Snoddon says:

    Plato opened up the ideology of looking beyond the immediate and everyday aspects of life. The Cave of course is the metaphor for our own imprisonment, our lives being shadows of the ideal “forms.”

  2. Tim Snoddon's avatar Tim Snoddon says:

    Cont.

    The path to rising above the illusions for Plato is through intellect. It is important also to note that to Plato, oneness is goodness. A monotheistic proposal. It goes without saying that at the core of the ideal of Christianity, as well as perhaps for Judaism and even Islam, Anxient Greece, with Plato/Socrates leading the way.

  3. Becky Myers's avatar Becky Myers says:

    I like that MacCulloch writes as a candid friend of Christianity, not a believer. This enables objectivity of history that I can digest and respect when absorbing. We read this Introduction and First Chapter as part of our Education for Ministry class, Year Three.

    The Greeks worshiped a passionless perfection in the oneness, the goodness, of God, while Israel worshiped a passionate, compassionate, loving and jealous God. Christianity is the reconciliation of these two interpretations.

    From Jeannie Babb’s EfM Study Guide of “Christianity: The First Three Thousand Years”:

    Christianity is, at root, a personality cult based on the story of a person believed to be the Christ.

    • Conversion and repentance are key concepts in the Christian vocabulary.
    • Christianity has usually been intolerant toward other faiths, except sometimes Judaism.
    • The Bible speaks with many voices and genres, including criticism of church or temple tradition
      (prophecy).
    • The history of Christianity diverged into three different language families:
      o Those who spoke Latin
      o Those who spoke Greek
      o Those who spoke Oriental languages
    • These language differences affected the development of theology, especially as the three
      groups sought to discuss the divine and human natures of Christ
    • Christianity is more uniform and unified now that at any point in history, even among these
      three groups and all the divisions in each of them.
    • Christianity has displayed an amazing ability to mutate (as have all the world faiths). Many
      Christians have trouble admitting this and prefer to believe it is unchanged from the beginning.

    Ekklesia (translated ‘church’ in the New Testament) is borrowed from Greek political vocabulary. In
    the polis (collective area occupied by citizens, including surrounding terrain), the ekklesia was an assembly of citizens who made decisions. While polis was the local form of
    Hellas (both signifying the culture as well as the political body), ekklesia in the New Testament and in
    church tradition could both expand and contract; that is, either a local congregation, or a group of
    congregations, or the entire Christian population might be called the ekklesia.

    Interesting, how a word meaning group of people making decisions became ecclesiastical in English, meaning of the church, with religious emphasis and culture, unifying politics and religion.

Leave a reply to Tim Snoddon Cancel reply